Hopkins had been attracted to asceticism since childhood. At Highgate, for instance, he argued that nearly everyone consumed more liquids than the body needed, and, to prove it, he wagered that he could go without liquids for at least a week. He persisted until his tongue was black and he collapsed at drill. He won not only his wager but also the undying enmity of the headmaster Dr. John Bradley Dyne. On another occasion, he abstained from salt for a week. His continuing insistence on extremes of self-denial later in life struck some of his fellow Jesuits as more appropriate to a Victorian Puritan than to a Catholic.
Thus it is important to realize that he converted to Catholicism not to be more ascetic, for asceticism was as Protestant as it was Catholic, but to be able to embrace the Catholic doctrine of the Real Presence. This explanation was not enough to satisfy his family, however.
Hopkins’s letter informing them of his conversion came as a great shock. He wrote to Newman: «I have been up at Oxford just long enough to have heard fr. my father and mother in return for my letter announcing my conversion. Their answers are terrible: I cannot read them twice.» Meanwhile, Manley Hopkins was writing to Gerard’s Anglican confessor, H.P. Liddon: «The blow is so deadly and great that we have not yet recovered from the first shock of it. We had observed a growing love for asceticism and high ritual, and/ … we believed he had lately resolved on taking orders in the English Church …. save him from throwing a pure life and a somewhat unusual intellect away in the cold limbo which Rome assigns to her English converts. The deepness of our distress, the shattering of our hopes and the foreseen estrangement which must happen, are my excuse for writing to you so freely.» After receiving Liddon’s reply, Manley Hopkins wrote to Liddon again, accusing Gerard of speaking «with perfect coldness of any possible estrangement from us, who have loved him with an unchanging love. His mother’s heart is almost broken by this, and by his desertion from our Church, her belief in, and devotion to, which are woven in with her very being.» Manley used similar terms in his letter to Gerard: «The manner in which you seem to repel and throw us off cuts us to the heart …. O Gerard my darling boy are you indeed gone from me?»
As these words suggest, when Hopkins converted to Catholicism he felt he had actually forfeited his rightful place in the family home; he did not even know if his father would let him in the house again. A letter from Hopkins reveals that his father consented to his presence there on one condition: «You are so kind as not to forbid me your house, to which I have no claim, on condition, if I understand, that I promise not to try to convert my brothers and sisters.» This was not an easy condition for him to accept, however; «Before I can promise this I must get permission, wh. I have no doubt will be given. Of course this promise will not apply after they come of age. Whether after my reception you will still speak as you do now I cannot tell.» Despite these differences Hopkins did spend his Christmas holidays with his family in 1866 and 1867, but what his father called «the foreseen estrangement which must happen» necessarily increased when Hopkins began his novitiate in the Society of Jesus at Manresa House, Roehampton, in September 1868 and later moved to St. Mary’s Hall, Stonyhurst, for his philosophical studies in 1870. He spent Christmas away from his family from 1868 to 1871. He returned to the family hearth for the holiday in subsequent years, but in 1885 his Dublin poems still testify to the lonely isolation and anticipation of death characteristic of many Victorian orphans:
To seem the stranger lies my lot, my life
Among strangers. Father and mother dear,
Brothers and sisters are in Christ not near
…………………………………
I am in Ireland now; now I am at a third
Remove. Not but in all removes I can
Kind love both give and get.
When, aged only forty-four, he was finally close to the farthest remove, death, another reconciliation was attempted, but it was too late. His was a painful and poignant tragedy all too typical of Victorian families.
Some of the most luminous symbols of the presence of God in Hopkins’s Welsh poems are the sunrises and the “sea-sunsets which give such splendour to the vale of Clwyd,”. Such sights were prized and distilled in Hopkins’s nature poetry in his imagery of sunlight which “sidled like dewdrops, like dandled diamonds” (“The furl of fresh-leaved dogrose down,” 1879). Everything from ploughed furrows to clouds to their reflections in pools is shining and gleaming. Even night reveals a world of strangely translucent moonshine or of stars that gleam like “bright boroughs” or “diamond delves” or “quickgold” in gray lawns; all of nature was perceived as a “piece-bright paling” that was Christ’s “home” (“The Starlight Night,” 1877).
Hopkins’s most famous Welsh sonnet, “The Windhover,” reveals that for him this Book of Nature, like the Bible, demanded a moral application to the self. Hopkins wrote in his notes on St. Ignatius: “This world is word, exprerssion, news of God”; “it is a book he has written…. a poem of beauty: what is it about? His praise, the reverence due to him, the way to serve him…. Do I then do it? Never mind others now nor the race of man: DO I DO IT?” One of Hopkins’s attempts to answer that question is “The Windhover.”
Hopkins wrote “The Windhover” only a few months before his ordination as a Jesuit priest, the ultimate commitment to sacrifice his worldly ambitions. Just as Jesus’ paradoxical triumph was his buckling under, his apparent collapse, so Hopkins felt that the knight of faith must be prepared for the same buckling under or collapse of his pride, for a life of “sheer plod” and “blue-bleak” self-sacrifice, if need be. Nevertheless, the imagery of “The Windhover” promises that the knight of faith will have a fire break from his heart then—galled, gashed, and crucified in imitation of Christ. The fire will be “a billion times told lovelier” than that of his “heart in hiding,” and far more “dangerous,” both to his old self (for the fire is all-consuming) and to his enemy, Evil.
In Hopkins’s case, the fire also became far more “dangerous” to his worldly poetic ambitions. Among other things, “The Windhover” represents Hopkins’s Pegasus, the flying steed of classical myth. The collapse of his old poetic self is implied in the imagery, for Bellerophon was thrown off Pegasus because of his pride. Fearing his pride in his own poetry, Hopkins burned his poems upon entering the Society of Jesus: he believed that poetry always had to give way, buckle under, to the “greater cause” of religion. As a result there was a very real danger that his poems would never reach the public they deserved, that he would have to sacrifice all the worldly fame promised him as “the star of Balliol” for a life of “sheer plod.”
The ultimate result of God’s withdrawal from the soul and the consequent darkness is often the temptation to despair, that loss of all hope which is the state of the damned in Dante’s Inferno. This despair, the temptation resisted in the opening of Hopkins’s “Carrion Comfort,” was the natural culmination of acedia according to John Chrysostom and others. Despair in turn often leads to the death wish, as implied in the conclusion of Hopkins’s “No worst,” in his “The Times are nightfall,” and in his lament in “To seem the stranger”: “Not but in all removes I can/Kind love both give and get.”
However, the conclusion of Hopkins’s “I wake and feel”—”The lost are like this, and their scourge to be/As I am mine, their sweating selves; but worse”—is an allusion to Dante which clearly distinguishes the speaker of Hopkins’s terrible sonnets from the damned who are continually referred to in the Inferno as “the lost” and the “sorrowful” who have lost all hope, even hope of death. Like Dante, Hopkins faced the “lost” and that which was most like them in his own soul, but his speaker also remains separated from the lost in that he is a living soul still addressing God in his prayers, still purging himself of his sins, and still living by hope in grace.
The ultimate context of Hopkins’s purgation, therefore, as of Dante’s, was the Bible. One of the biblical incidents echoed in the imagery and phraseology of “No worst,” for instance, is that of Jesus’ exorcism of the demons of Gadara. Like the imagery of Dante’s Purgatorio, this exorcism imagery obviously provides a significant counterpoint of meaning. The suggestion is that the speaker is attempting to herd and huddle all the demons of ennui together in one category, “world-sorrow,” and “heave” them out of himself. Hopkins’s sonnets of desolation are especially suited to this cathartic, purging function because they are prayers as well as poems. Like Jesus’ cry on the cross, Hopkins’s sonnets of desolation are addressed to God and are themselves consolations.
Eventually, Hopkins, like Dante, was granted a glimpse of Paradise. Hopkins’s sonnet of 1888, “That Nature is a Heraclitean Fire and of the comfort of the Resurrection,” is apparently a direct reply to “No worst, there is none”: the question in the earlier poem, “Comforter, where, where is your comforting?” is answered in the title of the later poem. Acedia has been conquered: “Enough! the Resurrection, /A heart’s clarion! Away grief’s gasping, joyless days, dejection.”As Dante put it, “The inborn and perpetual thirst for the godlike kingdom bore us away…. It seemed to me that a cloud covered us, shining, dense, solid and smooth; like a diamond smit by the sun.” Hopkins concludes this poem with similar imagery: “I am all at once what Christ is, since he was what I am, and / This Jack, joke, poor potsherd, patch, matchwood, immortal diamond, /Is immortal diamond.”
Once Hopkin’s nature poetry got placed, it can be discern some of the particular characteristics of his own didactism, also can be perceived through his nature poems a show of his contemporary precedents. Hopkin’s nature poems are divided in two periods, first one is a lament about environmental damages created by human beings. Hopkins’s early poetry praises nature, specially nature’s incomparable quality for regenerate and rejuvenate. In “God’s Grandeur,” the speaker can feel the source that links nature and humans. Hopkins became increasingly depressed by late nineteenth-century life even he never doubted the presence of God in nature, he started to doubt about nature’s ability to resist human destruction. At the so-called terrible sonnets, he focus on images of death, rather than show the glory of nature’s renascence, these poems picture the deaths that have to occur for the cycle of nature to proceed.
His unusually convincing religious poetry strike the reader in a more direct and imperative way, showing his Catholic beliefs first and Jesuit’s ones later on. Hopkins used poetry to express his religious devotion, drawing his images from the natural world. Then the recognition of an object’s unique identity, which was bestowed upon that object by God, brings us closer to Christ. Many poems, as “The Windhover,” begin with the articulator praising a nature feature, which later leads into a thought of an aspect of God or Christ.
I really hope that you have enjoyed the reading of this paper very much and that it would help you to approach to this poet who was so influenced by God and religion in such different time periods like Romanticism and the Victorian Era.
While his staying at Oxford college where he spend five years of studying until he graduated in 1867, Hopkins religious consciousness increased dramatically. There he became more aware of the religious implications of the medievalism of Ruskin, Dixon, and the Pre-Raphaelites.
His biggest inspirations in this affair were Christina Rossetti, the Catholic doctrine of the Real Presence of God in the Eucharist, and by the Victorian preoccupation with the fifteenth-century Italian religious reformer Girolamo Savonarola.
While he was at Oxford, apparently as a result of the tradition of oral contests and because of his own decision of focusing on classical studies, Hopkins’s consciousness of competition with contemporaries increased.
Hopkins’s teacher, Dixon, encouraged him to begin his literary career as a student of Keats’s, he also showed Hopkins how to resist Keats’s dominance. While the initiation and direction of Hopkins’s creativity in the relationship with Dixon was positive, Hopkins’s relationship with a more famous teacher at Oxford, Walter Pater, was fiercely dialectical, with Hopkins defining his position in opposition to Pater’s.
Both Hopkins and Christina Rossetti believed that religion was more important than art. The outline of Hopkins’s career follows that of Christina Rossetti’s: an outwardly drab, plodding life of submission quietly bursting into splendor in holiness and poetry. Both felt that religious inspiration was more important than artistic inspiration. Whenever religious renunciation and self-expression were felt to be at odds, as they often were, self-expression had to be sacrificed. Poetry had to be subordinated to religion. Hopkins was clearly oriented to the Pre-Raphaelite dream vision in which the poet is represented on a lower plane than the vision.
The attitudes of Christina Rossetti and Hopkins toward art and religion have destined them to share much the same fate at the hands of twentieth-century readers: criticism for deliberately narrowing their subjects to a range too limited for modern palates, for expressing religious convictions with which it is now difficult to sympathize, for allowing religion to take precedence over poetry, or for actually impairing the creative gift itself. On the other hand, both are often praised by twentieth-century readers for the same feature: the expression of counterpoised forces generating dramatic tensions.
One of the most dramatic tensions was that between their attraction to this world and their determination to transcend it. Like Hopkins, Christina Rossetti often reveals a Keatsian attraction to the life of sensations, especially to nature. Hopkins’s wide variety of responses to nature, especially in the 1860s and 1880s, ranging from strong attraction to its beauty to belief that this beauty must be denied on religious grounds, is congruent with the range of Christina Rossetti’s responses.
No doubt partly as a result of this attitude, both Hopkins and Rossetti were subject to intermittent creativity. Both thought of poetry as a gift which could not be summoned at will, and each turned to prose between bursts of poetic inspiration. In fact each went through a stage of about seven years in which writing prose almost entirely replaced composing poetry.
Hopkins’s prose period stretched from 1868 to 1875, when his literary energies were devoted primarily to his journal. In addition to passing through periods of writing prose, both poets concluded their literary careers with devotional commentaries: in Hopkins’s case, his unfinished «Commentary on the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius.»
During the last 5 years of his life several problems conspired to depress Hopkins’s spirits and restrict his poetic inspiration. He disliked living in Dublin «at a third remove» from England and friends, his work load was extremely heavy, his eyesightbegan to fail, and his general health deterioratedrapidly. He felt confined in a «coffin of weakness and dejection.» Moreover, as a devout Jesuit, he found himself in an artistic dilemma. He had decided never to publish his poetry, to subdueany egotismwhich would violate the humilityrequired by his religious position. But Hopkins realized that any true poet requires an audience for criticism as well as encouragement. This conflict between his religious obligations and his poetic talent caused him to feel that he had failed both.
Hopkins found himself «time’s eunuch, » religiously sterilebecause removed from God’s favor and poetically sterile because God is the religious poet’s inspiration. In this «winter world» Hopkins’s only solution was to make his religious sterility the subject matter of his seven «terrible sonnets … written in blood» in 1885. «To Seem the Stranger, » «I Wake and Feel the Fell of Dark, » «No Worst, There Is None» – poems which Hopkins said came to him «unbiddenand against my will» – record his deep despair, feeling of separation from God, and sense of personal worthlessness.
During the last 2 years of his life Hopkins wrote only five additional poems. Two of them still voice despair, but three climb toward renewed hope for reunion with God. The triumphant poem «That Nature Is a Heraclitean Fire and of the Comfort of the Resurrection» explains Hopkins’s dying words, «I am so happy.»
dom of daylight’s dauphin, dapple-dawn-drawn Falcon, in his riding
Of the rolling level underneath him steady air, and striding
High there, how he rung upon the rein of a wimpling wing
In his ecstasy! then off, off forth on swing,
As a skate’s heel sweeps smooth on a bow-bend: the hurl and gliding
Rebuffed the big wind. My heart in hiding
Stirred for a bird, – the achieve of, the mastery of the thing!
Brute beauty and valour and act, oh, air, pride, plume, here
Buckle! AND the fire that breaks from thee then, a billion
Times told lovelier, more dangerous, O my chevalier!
No wonder of it: shéer plód makes plough down sillion
Shine, and blue-bleak embers, ah my dear,
Fall, gall themselves, and gash gold-vermilion.
Summary
This poem follows the pattern of so many of Hopkins’s sonnets, in that a sensuous experience or description leads to a set of moral reflections. The beauty of the poem lies mostly in the way Hopkins has integrated the bird’s physical description blend with an account of his own heart’s response. However, the sestet has amazed many readers because it seems to diverge so widely from the material introduced in the octave. At line nine, the poem shifts into the present tense, away from the recollection of the bird. The transition between octave and sestet comes with the statement in lines 9-11 that the natural beauty of the bird in flight is but a spark in comparison with the glory of Christ, whose grandeur and spiritual power are “a billion times told lovelier, more dangerous.”
Durin the first sentence the culminating of the perfect self-expression can be read as a descriptive idea of something glorious happening when a physical body gots into accordance with God’s will, Hopkins, draws inspiration from the bird’s action when realizing that his own heart was not fully committed to his own purpose. Though man’s spiritual strenght, at those particular moments when humans arrive at the fullness of their moral nature, something great can be gained. But in comparison with the ultimate act of self-sacrifice performed by Christ, that greatness necessarily pales.
The final tercet within the sestet suggests that there is a glittering, luminous core to every individual, which a concerted religious life can expose. This phenomenon is not a “wonder,” but rather an everyday occurrence in human’s life. This striving, far from exhausting the individual, serves to bring out his or her inner glow causing it to sparkle and shine. The subsequent image reveals a smoldering interior of embers breaking open to.
Nothing is so beautiful as Spring —
When weeds in wheels, shoot long and lovely and lush;
Thrush’s eggs look little low heavens, and thrush
Through the echoing timber does so rinse and wring
The ear, it strikes like lightnings to hear him sing;
The glassy peartree leaves and blooms, they brush
The descending blue; that blue is all in a rush
With richness; the racing lambs too have fair their fling.
What is all this juice and all this joy?
A strain of the earth’s sweet being in the beginning
In Eden garden. — Have, get, before it cloy,
Before it cloud, Christ, lord and sour with sinning,
Innocent mind and Mayday in girl and boy,
Most, O maid’s child, thy choice and worthy the winning.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4ELZNn_PXo
Summary
This poem shows how Hopkins was heavily influenced by his religious background. the poem is written as a plea to God, Hopkins speaks of the beauty of nature and makes close references to the bible, «Eden Garden». in the poem he associates the beauty of Spring with the puritty of the Virgin Mary who is adaored by Catholics for her purity and lack of sin, this poem is an excellent example of the religious themes which Hopkins explored in many of his poems.
Glory be to God for dappled things—
For skies of couple-colour as a brinded cow;
For rose-moles all in stipple upon trout that swim;
Fresh-firecoal chestnut-falls; finches’ wings;
Landscape plotted and pieced—fold, fallow, and plough;
And áll trádes, their gear and tackle and trim.
All things counter, original, spare, strange;
Whatever is fickle, freckled (who knows how?)
With swift, slow; sweet, sour; adazzle, dim;
He fathers-forth whose beauty is past change: Praise Him.
Summary
The poem is thus a hymn of creation, praising God by praising the created world. Pied Beauty is a praise to God in which Hopkins shows off the charms of the natural world’s beauty. This poem looks like being set in a colourful world were the colour of skies and the fallen chestnuts are part of his creation, and form part of the simple and elegant beauty of this world. Where every God’s creation deserves a praise no matters how opposing, original, spare or strange. It expresses the theological position that the great variety in the natural world is a testimony to the perfect unity of God and the infinitude of His creative power. They are all, he avers, creations of God, which, in their multiplicity, point always to the unity and permanence of His power and inspire us to “Praise Him.”
The poem opens with an offering: “Glory be to God for dappled things.” In the next five lines, Hopkins elaborates with examples of what things he means to include under this rubric of “dappled.” He includes the mottled white and blue colors of the sky, the “brinded” hide of a cow, and the patches of contrasting color on a trout. The chestnuts offer a slightly more complex image: When they fall they open to reveal the meaty interior normally concealed by the hard shell; they are compared to the coals in a fire, black on the outside and glowing within. The wings of finches are multicolored, as is a patchwork of farmland in which sections look different according to whether they are planted and green, fallow, or freshly plowed. The final example is of the “trades” and activities of man, with their rich diversity of materials and equipment.
In the final five lines, Hopkins goes on to consider more closely the characteristics of these examples he has given, attaching moral qualities now to the concept of variety and diversity that he has elaborated thus far mostly in terms of physical characteristics.
As part of God’s work,the image transcends the physical, implying how the physical links the spiritual and meditating on the relationship between body and soul. Lines five and six then serve to connect these musings to human life and activity.
With “fickle” and “freckled” in the eighth line, Hopkins introduces a moral and an aesthetic quality, each of which would conventionally convey a negative judgment, in order to fold even the base and the ugly back into his worshipful inventory of God’s gloriously “pied” creation. In the context of a Victorian age that valued uniformity, efficiency, and standardization, this theological notion takes on a tone of protest.
Created almost in secret for the last Victorian period, the work of Gerard Manley Hopkins, one of the most intense and original-English poetry was not published until 1918, in a world without doubt better prepared to design both its formal searches, his anguish and despair as joy. Hopkins foresaw the disintegration of an order of things and, anticipating to it, violating the conventions to explore the deep tangle of will and nature, verb and incarnation, and reveal new ways to remain essential to life. He is a poet of duality does not seek to transcend but live it, and in fact there is another unit that harmony, a religious poet whose God only manifests itself to the senses.
In his own life, Hopkins struggled to procure a principle of cohesion through the pursuit of «the only visible Church.» Anglican, defended the third way, increasingly torn between Protestants and Romanizing trends to give after the latter. In 1866 he converted to Catholicism two years later he entered the novitiate of the Society of Jesus. For this reason destroyed much of his poetry and decided not to write more «for not being like my profession.»
But his theological studies led him to Duns Scotus, whose emphasis on the particular form (being-this) as final perfection of creation and starting point for any act of knowledge, came to corroborate the notion of inscape and penalize the exercise of individuality. Still, it was necessary that a superior urge the water to commemorate the death of five Franciscan nuns, to break his silence and Hopkins wrote his first and greatest masterpiece: The Wreck of the Deutschland (1876), which already fully manifested peculiar and vigorous diction and explores the possibilities of rate cut (sprung rhytm), which «is to scan only for accents, regardless of the number of syllables, so that a foot may consist of one strong syllable or many weak and a strong one.
When we place Hopkins’s nature poetry in this tradition we not only perceive the contemporary precedents for the homilies which conclude so many of his nature poems, we also begin to discern some of the distinguishing features of his didacticism. Hopkins’s commands strike us as more direct and imperative, and we discover that his religious poetry was unusually proselyptical before he became a Catholic and long before he became a Jesuit.
The relationship between Hopkins and his father reveals important early instances of creative collaboration and competition within the family. Hopkins copied eleven of the poems from his father’s volume A Philosopher’s Stone into his Oxford notebooks. In those poems his father expressed a Keatsian dismay over science’s threat to a magical or imaginative response to nature. Manley Hopkins’s desire to preserve a Wordsworthian love of nature in his children is evident in his «To a Beautiful Child».
Gerard’s response to nature was also influenced by a poem such as «A Bird Singing in a Narrow Street,» one of the eleven poems from The Philosopher’s Stone he copied into his notebook. This theme of the bird confined recurs most obviously in Gerard’s «The Caged Skylark» (1877) but may be detected even in comments on the imprisoning narrowness of urban civilization in his letters. In addition, the son answered the father’s representation of a bird filling the «throbbing air» with sound and «making our bosoms to thy cadence thrill» in «The Nightingale» (1866)
Competition and collaboration between father and son continued even long after Hopkins left home to take his place in the world. In 1879, for instance, Gerard Manley Hopkins wrote to Bridges, «I enclose some lines by my father called forth by the proposal to fell the trees in Well Walk (where Keats and other interesting people lived) and printed in some local paper.» Two months later Hopkins composed «Binsey Poplars» to commemorate the felling of a grove of trees near Oxford. Clearly, competition with his father was an important creative stimulus.
In addition to specific inspirations such as these, the father communicated to his son a sense of nature as a book written by God which leads its readers to a thoughtful contemplation of Him, a theme particularly evident in Manley and Thomas Marsland Hopkins’s book of poems, Pietas Metrica. Consequently, Gerard went on to write poems which were some of the best expressions not only of the Romantic approach to nature but also the older tradition of explicitly religious nature poetry.
The son clearly surpassed the father in many ways. For instance, the son resisted the temptation to become morbid better than the father’s example might lead one to expect.