Filed under: Uncategorized
What is more, there is a curious lack of serious exploration of the prose writings, particularly the devotional material. For example, the functioning of beauty for Hopkins and his subtle and sophisticated ideas of its working are surely not represented by an account which asserts that ‘in asking what beauty can do, no one should ignore the simplest answer of all-that it can bring pure bliss and ecstasy to the pysche. The poems are rich in concrete descriptions of beauty; but amid these, there are occasional soundings of this ecstatic response’ (p. 53). Then we have a list, summarizing what beauty does for man ‘in his state of spiritual dryness’:
i. It dramatically alters attention.
2. It makes him open to existing things.
3. It draws him to the goodness of being.
4. It sparks moral responsibility.
5. It brings ecstatic emotion. (p. 53)
Walhout likes lists, the three stages of feeling (ENG), the seven stages of response (p. 36), the five things beauty does (p. 53), the five types of evidence on which ‘the judgment of the power of grace in Hopkins’s life can be based’ (p. i 19). But they are simplistic rather than simplifying versions of Hopkins’s complex religious life and thought.
The book provides something for those who wish to see a tabulation of experience and a long paraphrase of Hopkins’s ideas-it is exposition rather than analysis; but it fails to put the religious experience into any context, to hint that there may be traditions behind Hopkins’s thought and expression and even behind his experience.
Jerome Bump’s book, on the other hand, is overweighted with tradition and
context, and bears the marks of a scholar firmly versed in and dedicated to its subject. Its place in Twayne’s English Authors Series might suggest an introductory essay and the Preface opens by describing the book as ‘primarily an introduction to Gerard Manley Hopkins’s contribution to our civilization’; but it is rather an attempt to place the man and his ideas in a tradition, and in doing this it often pursues the tradition at the expense of a convincing view of Hopkins’s place in it. In some ways this must derive from the book’s development and shape. Nearly all the chapters contain material from previously published articles which developed particular lines of argument on specific details, and these particular ideas-on the role of acedia or on typology for example-tend to appear like beads on a string rather than as a complete argument. The same development must have affected the
book’s loosely chronological-biographical shape. Bump is perhaps too aware of what has been written on Hopkins, and consciously tries to include new material and new approaches. The new photograph of Hopkins prose outside the central poems which are elsewhere so often, and so repetitively, explained. Even in considering ‘The Windhover’, Bump achieves a novelty of
approach, considering the poem according to the four levels of medieval biblical interpretation. The attempt does not quite come off, probably because the idea is applied too thoroughly and systematically; but the ideas come fresh. It is in fact curious that the focus of attention should be the over-zealously pursued associations and influences, since the brightest and freshest parts are the more straightforward and direct observations: the lively opening of the chapter on ‘A New Style’ which makes the important points about the oral quality of Hopkins’s poetry (though on pp. 76-7 a misunderstanding of the biblical ‘perform’ leads to some irrelevant paragraphs); the comments about transubstantiation and Incarnation,
subjects not usually given enough emphasis in writing on Victorian poetry; the treatment of the nature poems of the late seventies.
The book will not satisfy those who need a general introduction. Its attention to individual poems is uneven, its biographical skeleton not strong, and its centrifugal tendency to pursue detail works against its wholeness. But it is a book which contributes something new to our approach to Hopkins rather than simply repeat what has been done before.
R. K. R. THORNTON
Review: [untitled]
Author(s): R. K. R. ThorntonSource: The Review of English Studies, New Series, Vol. 35, No. 139 (Aug., 1984), pp. 409-411Published by: Oxford University PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/515809 .Accessed: 03/10/2011 16:44
Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>